When they have trouble sleeping, some people take magnesium supplements every day and later find it unusually difficult to fall asleep if they skip it even for a single day. At times like this, they may worry, “Could I now be unable to sleep without magnesium?” Is that concern unfounded, or is it reasonable to worry?

◇Difficulty sleeping after stopping magnesium is not a withdrawal symptom
Having trouble sleeping again after stopping magnesium does not mean that the body has become addicted to it. Unlike caffeine, nicotine and alcohol, magnesium is not a substance that causes withdrawal symptoms such as insomnia, headaches and tremors when discontinued. Dr. Esan Ali, an American internal medicine specialist, said, “Magnesium does not cause addiction like caffeine, nicotine or alcohol,” adding, “Stopping its use does not cause withdrawal symptoms or actual physiological cravings.”

However, psychological and behavioral dependence can develop, leading people to feel that they can sleep well only after taking magnesium. Repeatedly experiencing deep sleep after taking magnesium every night can create a psychological reliance on it. On days when they do not take magnesium, they may instead find it difficult to relax and fall asleep.

◇People who were originally deficient may see previous symptoms return after stopping
There may be another explanation for people who did not normally consume enough magnesium. If their sleep improved after supplements replenished insufficient magnesium, their previous symptoms may reappear after stopping, making it feel like withdrawal.

Heewon L. Gray, an associate professor in the Department of Nutrition at the University of South Florida, said, “Symptoms of hypomagnesemia, a condition in which the magnesium concentration in the blood is low, can include sleep disturbances and insomnia,” adding, “If someone who did not normally consume enough magnesium through their diet took supplements for sleep, they may feel dependent when they stop taking them.”

If you cannot sleep after stopping magnesium, it is worth examining both your usual magnesium intake and your sleep habits rather than immediately turning back to supplements. Magnesium is found in abundance in green leafy vegetables, nuts, seeds, legumes and whole grains, so it is a good idea to make sure to eat these foods regularly. It is also advisable to check whether you drink caffeine late in the day, look at your smartphone until just before going to sleep, or have a different bedtime every day.

◇What requires caution is toxicity rather than addiction
The main concern related to magnesium is magnesium toxicity, in which excessive intake causes the concentration of magnesium in the blood to rise abnormally. According to the U.S. National Institutes of Health, NIH, healthy people are unlikely to develop problems even if they consume a large amount of magnesium through food because the kidneys excrete the excess in urine. However, consuming large amounts of supplements or medications containing magnesium can cause diarrhea, nausea and abdominal cramps.

The upper intake limit for magnesium for adults is 350 mg per day. Long-term magnesium intake at levels far exceeding this amount can also cause toxic reactions in the body. For example, cases of magnesium toxicity have been reported in the United States after people consumed very large amounts of antacids containing more than 5,000 mg of magnesium per day. People who obtain magnesium from multiple products need to check their total intake.

People with reduced kidney function need to be especially careful. This is because magnesium can build up in the body when the kidneys’ ability to excrete it declines. As magnesium toxicity becomes severe, it can cause low blood pressure, muscle weakness, difficulty breathing and an irregular heartbeat, and in extreme cases, it can lead to cardiac arrest.